Melbourne Cup Tips 2017 | Who Will Win | The Experts Break It Down

6 November, 2017

LEO SCHLINK (Herald Sun chief racing reporter)

1. MARMELO

2. Wall Of Fire

3. Almandin

Roughie: Red Cardinal

MICHAEL MANLEY (Herald Sun)

1. Almandin

2. Johannes Vermeer

3. Marmelo

Roughie: Big Duke

SIMON MOY (Superracing)

1. BIG DUKE

2. Almandin

3. Marmelo

Roughie: Reklindinig

CHRIS VERNUCCIO (Superracing)

1. MARMELO

2. Almandin

3. Tiberian

Roughie: Wicklow Brave

GLENN McFARLANE (Herald Sun)

1. HUMIDOR

2. Almandin

3. Marmelo

Roughie: Single Gaze

GILBERT GARDINER (Herald Sun)

1. WALL OF FIRE

2. Almandin

3. Humidor

Roughie: Secret Gaze

RAY THOMAS (Daily Telegraph racing editor)

1. RED CARDINAL

2. Marmelo

3. Johannes Vermeer

Roughie: Single Gaze

BRAD DAVIDSON (Racing reporter)

1. MARMELO

2. Red Cardinal

3. Tiberian

Roughie: Nakeeta

DARREN PRENDERGAST (Superracing)

1. JOHANNES VERMEER

2. Marmelo

3. Red Cardinal

Roughie: Hartnell

RON DUFFICY (Sky Thoroughbred Central)

1. WALL OF FIRE

2. Almandin

3. Marmelo

Roughie: Thomas Hobson

GARY CRISPE (Timeform)

1. HUMIDOR

2. Marmelo

3. Wall Of Fire

Roughie: Rekindling

NATHAN EXELBY (The Courier-Mail racing editor)

1. MARMELO

2. Wall Of Fire

3. Johannes Vermeer

Roughie: Red Cardinal

ROBERT CRADDOCK (The Courier-Mail chief sports writer)

1. JOHANNES VERMEER

2. Rekindling

3. Red Cardinal

Roughie: Wicklow Brave

SHAYNE O’CASS (Sportsman)

1. MARMELO

2. Tiberian

3. Red Cardinal

Roughie: Boom Time

PAUL MICALLEF (Sportsman)

1. JOHANNES VERMEER

2. Marmelo

3. Humidor

Roughie: Hartnell